From: 	Jeff Tarling
To:	Helen Donaldson
Date: 	10/25/2012 1:51 PM
Subject: 	Fore Street Project

Hi Nel -

I have reviewed the proposed landscape plan and tree planting for the proposed 
hotel project on Fore Street and find the plan acceptable.  Due to the narrow 
width of sidewalk along Fore Street we would recommend tree grates, either
the NEENAH R-8810 (36"x60") or the R-8811 (48"x72") grate.  The greater the 
soil volume in the proposed sidewalk tree pit the better for the tree.  Deicing salt
is one of the biggest challenges for urban tree survivability, in many areas we like
to see the use of raised granite tree wells to reduce salt and compaction - this site
is somewhat limited.  The applicant will need to ensure that the proposed 3" tree
which has a minumum rootball width of 32" spec can fit into the space.
 
The proposed planting of Bayberry and Viburnum should provide a hardy, native plant
type in other areas.
 
Jeff Tarling
City Arborist